Clinical Application of Law and Ethics in the Face of Extraordinary Decisions: Insights from the Italian Healthcare Crisis

QUESTION

This is as simple as I can get it,  I need a synthesis to make a video presentation.

Description: Clinical application of law and ethics

relevant standards Professional standards: applicable for this paper

  • NMBA 1,3,4,5,6,7.

I need information synthesis to start to build my video presentation to which to educate my peers in the clinical environment.

 

Information I need is a synthesis – 

explain/define what the concepts are, used in the clinical situation presented in the scenario below –

The Extraordinary Decisions Facing Italian Doctors There are now simply too many patients for each one of them to receive adequate care.

By Yascha Mounk

A synthesis will help me – Demonstrate to peers my knowledge and understanding of the content listed below, as it applies to the clinical situation –

I need to demonstrate how each applies in the clinical situation, and the relevant professional nursing legislation that influences Australian nurses’ decision-making in such situations, The Registered Nurse Standards for Practice, the ICN Code of Ethics for Nurses https://www.ahpra.gov.au/documents/default.aspx?record=WD21%2f31394&dbid=AP&chksum=%2fYe7Wsutxzjzs4cCDgR%2bEA%3d%3d

The concepts are:

  • An ethical dilemma faced by the nurses;
  • Utilitarianism and Deontology
  • Duty of Care and Fidelity
  • Beneficence, Non-Maleficence
  • Justice including Distributive justice
  • The Tort of Negligence including the elements of Negligence/Acts and Omissions.

– demonstrate similarities, differences, relationships and conflicts between the different concepts/groups of concepts by discussing  two main ethical theories of Utilitarianism and Deontology.

discuss them together demonstrating the differences.

Demonstrate – knowledge of the relationship between content, the clinical environment and professional legislation.

 

References – be within 5 years of publication only. References should be from a valid source (peer-reviewed journals, government organisations, and professional online websites and resources e.g., Department of Health, Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia etc.). the legislation must be relevant to Australia. References should support ethical and legal/professional information as opposed to clinical information.

References (in text) and end text or end of the presentation reference list.

PAPER to read 

The Atlantic, March 12 2020

The Extraordinary Decisions Facing Italian Doctors

There are now simply too many patients for each one of them to receive adequate care.

By Yascha Mounk

 

Two weeks ago, Italy had 322 confirmed cases of the coronavirus. At that point, doctors in the country’s hospitals could lavish significant attention on each stricken patient.

One week ago, Italy had 2,502 cases of the virus, which causes the disease known as COVID-19. At that point, doctors in the country’s hospitals could still perform the most lifesaving functions by artificially ventilating patients who experienced acute breathing difficulties.

Today, Italy has 10,149 cases of the coronavirus. There are now simply too many patients for each one of them to receive adequate care. Doctors and nurses are unable to tend to everybody. They lack machines to ventilate all those gasping for air.

Now the Italian College of Anaesthesia, Analgesia, Resuscitation and Intensive Care (SIAARTI) has published guidelines for the criteria that doctors and nurses should follow as these already extraordinary circumstances worsen. The document begins by likening the moral choices Italian doctors may face to the forms of wartime triage that are required in the field of “catastrophe medicine.” Instead of providing intensive care to all patients who need it, the authors suggest, it may become necessary to follow “the most widely shared criteria regarding distributive justice and the appropriate allocation of limited health resources.”

The principle they settle upon is utilitarian. “Informed by the principle of maximizing benefits for the largest number,” they suggest that “the allocation criteria need to guarantee that those patients with the highest chance of therapeutic success will retain access to intensive care.”

The authors, who are medical doctors, then deduce a set of concrete recommendations for how to manage these impossible choices, including this: “It may become necessary to establish an age limit for access to intensive care.”

Those who are too old to have a high likelihood of recovery, or who have too low a number of “life-years” left even if they should survive, would be left to die. This sounds cruel, but the alternative, the document argues, is no better. “In case of a total saturation of resources, maintaining the criterion of ‘first come, first served’ would amount to a decision to exclude late-arriving patients from access to intensive care.”

In addition to age, doctors and nurses are also advised to take a patient’s overall state of health into account: “The presence of comorbidities needs to be carefully evaluated.” This is in part because early studies of the virus seem to suggest that patients with serious pre-existing health conditions are significantly more likely to die. But it is also because patients in a worse state of overall health could require a greater share of scarce resources to survive: “What might be a relatively short treatment course in healthier people could be longer and more resource-consuming in the case of older or more fragile patients.”

These guidelines apply even to patients who require intensive care for reasons other than the coronavirus, because they too make demands on the same scarce medical resources. As the document clarifies, “These criteria apply to all patients in intensive care, not just those infected with CoVid-19.”

My academic training is in political and moral philosophy. I have spent countless hours in fancy seminar rooms discussing abstract moral dilemmas like the so-called trolley problem. If a train is barreling toward five innocent people who are tied to the tracks, and I could divert it by pulling the lever, but at the cost of killing an innocent bystander, should I do it?

Part of the point of all those discussions was, supposedly, to help professionals make difficult moral choices in real-world circumstances. If you are an overworked nurse battling a novel disease under the most desperate circumstances, and you simply cannot treat everyone, however hard you try, whose life should you save?

Despite those years of theory, I must admit that I have no moral judgment to make about the extraordinary document published by those brave Italian doctors. I have not the first clue whether they are recommending the right or the wrong thing.

But if Italy is in an impossible position, the obligation facing the United States is very clear: To arrest the crisis before the impossible becomes necessary.

This means that our political leaders, the heads of business and private associations, and every one of us need to work together to accomplish two things: Radically expand the capacity of the country’s intensive-care units. And start engaging in extreme forms of social distancing.

ANSWER

Clinical Application of Law and Ethics in the Face of Extraordinary Decisions: Insights from the Italian Healthcare Crisis

Introduction

The interplay between law, ethics, and healthcare decisions is of paramount importance, especially during challenging times. This synthesis explores the clinical application of law and ethics in a scenario from the Italian healthcare crisis. By dissecting the provided case and aligning it with relevant professional standards, ethical theories, and legal considerations, this presentation aims to enhance the understanding of ethical dilemmas and decision-making processes in the clinical environment.

Ethical Dilemmas Faced by Italian Doctors

The scenario describes a dire situation where Italian doctors are overwhelmed by an influx of COVID-19 patients. The Italian College of Anaesthesia, Analgesia, Resuscitation, and Intensive Care (SIAARTI) has released guidelines that address the difficult moral choices medical professionals must confront. They liken the situation to wartime triage, emphasizing the need to allocate limited resources efficiently.

Ethical Concepts and Clinical Application

1. Utilitarianism and Deontology: The ethical theories of utilitarianism and deontology play a pivotal role in these extraordinary decisions. The principle of maximizing benefits for the largest number, inherent to utilitarianism, guides the allocation of limited health resources. Deontological principles, emphasizing duty and moral rules, factor into age-based decisions and overall state of health assessment.

2. Duty of Care and Fidelity: The duty of care to patients remains a cornerstone. Healthcare providers have a fiduciary responsibility to prioritize patients’ well-being and ensure access to intensive care for those with the highest chance of therapeutic success.

3. Beneficence, Non-Maleficence, and Justice: The principles of beneficence and non-maleficence drive the intention to provide the best possible outcomes while minimizing harm. Justice, encompassing distributive justice, mandates fair and equitable allocation of resources based on therapeutic success chances.

4. Tort of Negligence:The situation underscores the complexities of the tort of negligence. Decisions made under strained circumstances should be diligent and align with professional standards to avoid potential legal implications.

Clinical Situation and Professional Standards

In the Italian scenario, doctors must consider patients’ age, overall health, and comorbidities to allocate scarce resources. This aligns with professional standards, such as the NMBA Codes, that emphasize patient-centered care, informed decision-making, and ensuring patients’ rights and dignity.

Conclusion

The Italian crisis compels healthcare professionals to navigate intricate ethical dilemmas and make extraordinary decisions. By grounding these decisions in principles such as utilitarianism, deontology, duty of care, and justice, healthcare providers can attempt to optimize outcomes under strained circumstances. The intersection of law, ethics, and healthcare necessitates adherence to professional standards and the recognition of patients’ rights and well-being. As we examine this scenario, we gain valuable insights into the complexities of clinical application of law and ethics, enriching our understanding of ethical healthcare decision-making.

Calculate the price of your order

550 words
We'll send you the first draft for approval by September 11, 2018 at 10:52 AM
Total price:
$26
The price is based on these factors:
Academic level
Number of pages
Urgency
Basic features
  • Free title page and bibliography
  • Unlimited revisions
  • Plagiarism-free guarantee
  • Money-back guarantee
  • 24/7 Customer support
On-demand options
  • Tutor’s samples
  • Part-by-part delivery
  • Overnight delivery
  • Attractive discounts
  • Expert Proofreading
Paper format
  • 275 words per page
  • 12 pt Arial/Times New Roman
  • Double line spacing
  • Any citation style (APA, MLA, Chicago/Turabian, Harvard)

Unique Features

As a renowned provider of the best writing services, we have selected unique features which we offer to our customers as their guarantees that will make your user experience stress-free.

Money-Back Guarantee

Unlike other companies, our money-back guarantee ensures the safety of our customers' money. For whatever reason, the customer may request a refund; our support team assesses the ground on which the refund is requested and processes it instantly. However, our customers are lucky as they have the least chances to experience this as we are always prepared to serve you with the best.

Zero-Plagiarism Guarantee

Plagiarism is the worst academic offense that is highly punishable by all educational institutions. It's for this reason that Peachy Tutors does not condone any plagiarism. We use advanced plagiarism detection software that ensures there are no chances of similarity on your papers.

Free-Revision Policy

Sometimes your professor may be a little bit stubborn and needs some changes made on your paper, or you might need some customization done. All at your service, we will work on your revision till you are satisfied with the quality of work. All for Free!

Privacy And Confidentiality

We take our client's confidentiality as our highest priority; thus, we never share our client's information with third parties. Our company uses the standard encryption technology to store data and only uses trusted payment gateways.

High Quality Papers

Anytime you order your paper with us, be assured of the paper quality. Our tutors are highly skilled in researching and writing quality content that is relevant to the paper instructions and presented professionally. This makes us the best in the industry as our tutors can handle any type of paper despite its complexity.