Unearthing Unethical Behavior: Implications for the Three Identical Strangers

QUESTION

The film “Three Identical Strangers” is filled with unethical behavior by the adoption
agency, researchers, and the two professionals from the CDC project presented in this
documentary. Using readings/videos, such as James’ ‘The Will to Believe”,
Caruso’s “The Dark Side of Free Will”, Gazzaniga’s “How Free is Your Will” and in the
textbook, Kant’s “The Categorical Imperative”, existential philosophical perspectives
and issues of determinism. Discuss the implications of the unethical behavior.
as experienced by the three brothers.

ANSWER

Unearthing Unethical Behavior: Implications for the Three Identical Strangers

The documentary “Three Identical Strangers” intricately weaves a narrative of reunited triplets separated at birth, offering a gripping tale of both the joys of brotherhood and the dark underbelly of unethical behavior perpetrated by the adoption agency, researchers, and professionals involved. Drawing insights from philosophical perspectives, including existentialism, determinism, and moral philosophy, this essay delves into the profound implications of the unethical behavior experienced by the three brothers, illuminating the far-reaching consequences of these actions.

Unethical Behavior and the Human Experience

The ethical dilemma faced by the adoption agency, researchers, and CDC professionals represents a collision between the pursuit of knowledge and the respect for individual rights. The documentary highlights how the triplets’ lives were manipulated without their consent or awareness, raising questions about autonomy, determinism, and the ethical bounds of human inquiry.

Existential Philosophical Perspectives

Existentialism delves into the essence of individual existence and the responsibility individuals have in creating meaning for their lives. In the case of the triplets, their identities were tampered with, causing existential disruptions. The separation at birth denied them the agency to shape their own destinies, violating the existential principle of self-determination and personal growth.

Determinism and Ethical Implications

Determinism posits that our actions are influenced by factors beyond our control, challenging the notion of free will. The triplets’ lives were undeniably shaped by external forces, raising ethical questions about the responsibilities of institutions to respect individuals’ autonomy. The unethical decisions made by the adoption agency and researchers stripped the triplets of opportunities to exercise their free will, shattering the moral imperative to respect human agency.

Moral Philosophy and Kant’s Categorical Imperative

Immanuel Kant’s Categorical Imperative emphasizes treating individuals as ends in themselves, respecting their inherent worth and autonomy. The unethical actions of the adoption agency and researchers treated the triplets as means to achieve research objectives, disregarding their humanity and emotional well-being. This violation of Kant’s ethical principle underscores the profound disregard for the triplets’ dignity.

Impact on the Three Brothers

The consequences of the unethical behavior manifested in the triplets’ lives in profound and lasting ways. The shock of discovering their forced separation amplified existential crises, evoking questions about their true identities and life experiences. The lack of agency over their lives underlines the emotional turmoil experienced by the brothers, as they navigated the consequences of decisions made on their behalf.

In conclusion, the documentary “Three Identical Strangers” serves as a poignant testament to the implications of unethical behavior on the human experience. From existential crises and ethical violations to the suppression of free will and autonomy, the triplets’ lives were profoundly affected by the actions of the adoption agency, researchers, and professionals involved. This narrative serves as a stark reminder of the enduring impact of ethical transgressions on the lives of those subjected to them. By analyzing this complex web of unethical behavior through the lenses of philosophical perspectives, determinism, and moral philosophy, we gain insights into the multi-faceted ramifications of the choices made by those in positions of power.